Top 10 Brick Fireplace Makeover Ideas

Turn your dated brick fireplace into a jaw-dropping focal point.

We’re gearing up to tackle the *currently* ugly brick fireplace from the 60’s that’s been hiding in our basement.

Here’s what it looks like mid-reno:

Weird color. Weird texture.

It needs some love.

So I’ve rounded up the ten BEST types of DIY brick fireplace makeover ideas that are reasonably budget friendly. Let me know which one would be the best for this ancient gem. 😉

Happy fireplace refreshing!

Option 1: Paint it white

Ah, white paint. The ugly brick go-to.

I’m usually not a fan.

But, well, these are just WOW.

So what’s the trick to make white paint work?

Per Studio McGee, “Statements on fireplaces are one of our favorite details, especially when it’s painted brick. Paired with a cast concrete surround, it was the perfect way to center two built-ins on either side.”

If you’re dealing with dated brick you need to do more than just paint it. Paint can’t hide dated architecture. So whether you do a concrete surround, or a chunky wood beam, just remember to add a standout focal point.

But alas, our brick has weird grooves on the face… so white paint would be an obvious bandaid.

Option 2: Paint it an ‘exposed brick’ color

Not everyone has access to bricks from the 1800’s. But I’m interested in faking it.

But how to smoothe out our oddly ridged bricks… probably with joint compound. That was a miracle worker for our stone fireplace refresh. I’d probably use the same secret matte paint trick, too.

Part art project, part home improvement.

Hmmm… yes. My DIY brain likes this latest messy scheme.

Option 3: Shiplap

Modern farmhouse with neutrals? I’m in. Shiplap continues to show it’s lovely face, just with a less farm signs, and more elements of subtle texture.

Option 4: Cement or Roman Clay

Sleek and contemporary. From what I’ve read, real cement needs to be hired out, but there are great faux cement options. Or you can try Roman Clay! Angela said Roman Clay can be applied by regular DIY and ended up costing less than $100.

I’m definitely into that price tag.

Option 5: Tile

Tile opens up a LOT of possibilities. Patterns, color, texture—classy all around. Now a floor to ceiling tile fireplace would be GORGEOUS! But it’s probably on the spendier side.

Good news: even framing your fireplace and updating your hearth will still add the wow factor with less of the ouch factor to your wallet.

Option 6: Stone overlay

Look at this pretty stone I found at Lowes! I *think* it’s called Summit Ice Ledgerstone.

If you’re dreaming of a stone fireplace, try a thin stone overlay from a home improvement store, or AirStone like Andrea did over at Pine and Prospect.

Option 7: Stucco

Clean lines, with a bit of warm sandy texture. If your brick needs to be covered, or you’d like to extend your fireplace to the ceiling, give stucco a try! Stucco can even be painted if you change your mind about the color.

Ah! Seriously considering this option too. It’s a pretty good back up if my antique brick experiment turns south.

Option 8: Reclaimed Mantle

While this reclaimed wood fireplace surround is technically a gorgeous faux fireplace, imagine this in front of white painted brick for a charming focal point.

Reclaimed wood will always have a soft spot in my heart.

Option 9: Wood

Craftberry Bush and Studio McGee both nailed the moody dark fireplace! Cover up your brick with wood for a totally different look.

Option 10: German Schmear

This is best if you love the shape of your brick fireplace, but the brick is too dark. German schmear is Joanna Gains approved and farmhouse swoonworthy.

Now, time for the big decision!

What’s your vote on how to refresh our basement fireplace? Let me know in the comments. 🙂

Up Next: DIY Giant Fall Wreath